Karthauserhof Riesling Auslese #53 2004 375 ML

93 points Wine Spectator

 This is forward initially, showing apricot, lime and dried apple notes before the bracing acidity sweeps in and leaves a citrus tanginess on the palate. Similar to an eiswein in character, with a sweet-tart profile. It needs time to integrate. Best from 2008 through 2030. (BS, Web Only-2006) 

92 points Vinous

 Pale golden yellow. Full-blown aromas of papaya, passion fruit and loads of botrytis. The rich, unctuous tropical fruit flavors coat the palate. More creamy than elegant or delicate, but certainly savory and very long on the aftertaste. (JP)  (1/2006)